?

Log in

Previous Entry | Next Entry

On fake geek girls and "credentials"

So, Seanan wrote this post yesterday, which you should totally read (if you haven't already), and as I commented on it, I realized that I had a lot more to say than would fit in a comment. And then vixy wrote this, and the thoughts started bouncing around in my brain some more. This has been in my head since I first heard about this video (The Doubleclicks, "Nothing to Prove"). I had wanted to submit something, but I couldn't figure out what I wanted to say.

I haven't always identified as a geek, but I've always been geeky. My dad was always a fan of fantasy and SF. He introduced me to Lord of the Rings and Star Trek (he taped every episode of TOS on VHS). I was a regular fixture at my local public library, and I burned through the fantasy section (I don't have a clear memory of everything I read back in those days, other than there being a lot of Piers Anthony...). I wore out a VHS tape of The Last Unicorn, and when I saw The Princess Bride for the first time, it promptly became one of my all-time favorite movies. But with the exception of a couple of good friends I could occasionally geek out with, I didn't really travel in geeky circles as a teen.

I didn't read comics. I didn't play video games. The internet didn't even exist until I was in college.

(Once the internet existed, though? I was all over it.)

After college, I started to really embrace my geekiness, little by little. I got into geeky TV shows, like The X Files and Buffy.I discovered Harry Potter. I made friends with some fabulous geeky ladies in an online writing group (which later led to Toasted Cheese).

But it wasn't until much later (2004, to be exact) that I really got introduced to the whole idea of fandom. That happened when I met my husband. (If you click the link, the one on the left is mine.) He read comic books, and played music at science fiction conventions, and was part of this thing called filk (which, I should add, I had been introduced to before meeting him, by way of one of my Toasted Cheese friends). He started bringing me with him to filk conventions in 2005, and I kept going back.

It might be because of Rand, or it might be that I don't go to large gen cons like SDCC or DragonCon, but no one has ever asked me to prove myself, or questioned my credentials as a geek girl. Still, whenever this topic comes up, I can't help but feel a little bit anxious.

Because I'm afraid, if questioned, I would fail.

I read some comics, but I haven't read all the comics. I haven't seen all the right movies, or all the right TV shows, or read all the right books (some I'm interested in and just haven't gotten to them yet; others, I'm simply not interested in at all). And there's a little tiny part of me that wonders if people think I'm only part of this world because of Rand.

And every time I catch myself slipping into this line of thinking, I have to kind of shake myself out of it.

I am not a fake geek girl.

I am not a fake geek girl because the fake geek girl is a myth.

And I am a part of this community because I choose to be.

It may be true that, technically, I am here because of Rand (would I have found my own way without him? who knows...)--but I stuck around because of me.

Because, although I don't think either one of us really knew it at the time, when he brought me to that first convention...

...he was bringing me home.

Comments

( 4 comments — Leave a comment )
filkerdave
Aug. 2nd, 2013 02:41 am (UTC)
Thank you so much for this. Just one thing:

I read some comics, but I haven't read all the comics. I haven't seen all the right movies, or all the right TV shows, or read all the right books (some I'm interested in and just haven't gotten to them yet; others, I'm simply not interested in at all).

I haven't read comics on a regular basis in nigh on 20 years. I don't watch TV either, not since the first season of Heroes and before that I think it was Babylon 5. Books? I do my reading to vote for (not nominate for) the Hugos. Of course, because I'm male, nobody ever things I'm only there for Rand ;)

But no, you wouldn't fail, any more than I would. Because, as you say, you choose to be part of the crazy world we call fandom.

Yeah. Home. It's like that.
judifilksign
Aug. 4th, 2013 05:12 pm (UTC)
Welcome home!

I use my geek comic knowledge in my classroom, and I will sometimes get, "Do they make girls like you, or did you learn this as an adult?" from the guys. They are then astonished to learn there ARE geek girls in the same classroom, who have been quiet and thinking no one would like them because they were weird.
orangemike
Jan. 18th, 2014 03:51 am (UTC)
Gobba, gobba, we accept you;
We accept you, one of us!


You were never mundane; you just hadn't been found by your tribe yet. You are ours, and no "fake" whatsoever.
ebenbrooks
Jan. 18th, 2014 01:17 pm (UTC)
Wow! The exact same three things—the posts by Seanan and Vixy and the Doubleclicks' song—inspired me to write about my own feelings on this pernicious vein of nerdboy rage that is poisoning our community. It came out as a filk song, which I called "Geeky Girls".



We've got to keep flushing these guys out into the open where they can suffer the opprobrium that they deserve for their ridiculously sexist and elitist behavior.
( 4 comments — Leave a comment )

Latest Month

November 2016
S M T W T F S
  12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
27282930   

Tags

Powered by LiveJournal.com
Designed by Tiffany Chow